Rate the NFL Head Coaches

painekiller · #1 12-02-2008, 11:32 PM

Want to try something? Let's rate the HC in the NFL.

32 Herm Edwards KC
31 Jack Del Rio Jags
30 Mike Singletary SF
29 Tom Cable Oakland
28 Rod Marinelli Detroit
27 Brad Childress Minn
26 Marvin Lewis Cin
25 Romeo Crennel Cle
24 Jim Haslett Rams
23 Norv Turner Chargers
22 Lovie Smith Chi
21 Wade Phillips Dallas
20 Sean Payton NO
19 Mike Holmgren Seattle
18 Jim Zorn Was
17 Mike McCarthy GB
16 Dick Jauron Buf
15 Eric Mangini NYJ
14 Gary Kubiak Houston
13 Ken Whisenhunt Arizona
12 Tony Sparano Mia.
11 John Harbaugh Balt.
10 Mike Smith Atl
09 Tom Coughlin NYG
08 Mike Tomlin Pitts
07 John Fox Carolina
06 Mike Shanahan Den
05 Andy Reid Eagles
04 Jon Gruden Tampa
03 Jeff Fisher Tenn
02 Tony Dungy Indy
01 Bill Belichick NE

Is Kubiak this good or do I have him over rated based on his record? Remember he has had less talent to work with, next season should be the acid test year.

I have some big names near the bottom, disagree?

And who do you see as the next coordinator that will be named a HC? (Mora doesn't count) Jim Schwartz Titans DC, and /or Steve Spagnuolo Giants DC

Nconroe · #2 12-03-2008, 02:33 AM

Wow, this is a tought one, but my initial reaction is you have the ranking about right. gotta think / study about this some more.

barrett · #3 12-03-2008, 05:33 PM

I didn't bother changing the numbers. Also I ranked them over how good a coach they are, not just how they have been this year. What is amazing to me is I am pretty sure that only the top 6 have actually won a superbowl. Also I think it is tough to compare a Rookie head coach with 10 games experience with a guy with 10 years.

29 Tom Cable Oakland
28 Rod Marinelli Detroit
26 Marvin Lewis Cin
21 Wade Phillips Dallas
24 Jim Haslett Rams
30 Mike Singletary SF
23 Norv Turner Chargers
25 Romeo Crennel Cle
20 Sean Payton NO
31 Jack Del Rio Jags
32 Herm Edwards KC
27 Brad Childress Minn
14 Gary Kubiak Houston
18 Jim Zorn Was
17 Mike McCarthy GB
16 Dick Jauron Buf
13 Ken Whisenhunt Arizona
12 Tony Sparano Mia.
11 John Harbaugh Balt.
10 Mike Smith Atl
07 John Fox Carolina
15 Eric Mangini NYJ
05 Andy Reid Eagles
22 Lovie Smith Chi
08 Mike Tomlin Pitts
03 Jeff Fisher Tenn
09 Tom Coughlin NYG
19 Mike Holmgren Seattle
02 Tony Dungy Indy
04 Jon Gruden Tampa
06 Mike Shanahan Den
01 Bill Belichick NE

painekiller · #4 12-03-2008, 06:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by barrett

Also I think it is tough to compare a Rookie head coach with 10 games experience with a guy with 10 years.

I agree completely.