FF Discussion

[nero THE zero]

I'm mulling over a pretty big trade in one of my leagues and I'd like to get you guys' opinion on it. I'm running it through the FBG Rate-My-Team app and it says that it makes my team worse, but I don't know that I agree.

The league is a PPR, dynasty league with standard scoring.

My current roster exists as such:

QB:
David Garrard
JaMarcus Russell
Matt Stafford
Kerry Collins
Josh Johnson

RB:
DeAngelo Williams
Derrick Ward
Donald Brown
Ray Rice
Ricky Williams
Ladell Betts
Cadillac Williams
BenJarvus Green-Ellis

WR:
Andre Johnson
Reggie Wayne
Donnie Avery
Chris Henry
Greg Camarillo
Deion Branch
Brandon Lloyd
Jason Hill

TE:
John Carlson
Vernon Davis
Martellus Bennett

PK
Rob Bironas

DEF
NY Giants
TB Bucs

Now, I'm mulling over this trade proposal. Obviously it hasn't been accepted yet, and might not be. But, I'd like to be sure that it improves my team before I offer it.

I'd be offering:
JaMarcus Russell, DeAngelo Williams, and Reggie Wayne for Matt Schaub, Adrian Peterson, and a 2010 2nd round pick

Obviously it's going to hurt to trade a #1 WR and RB for a #1 RB. But, I feel that AD will be a legit top 3 RB for the next several years. DeAngelo has the question of Jonathan Stewart hanging over his head, and Reggie Wayne has the issues of age and coaching changes.

On the flip side, Wayne's been a sure-fire #1 WR for the past few years and is a nice pairing with AJ. And, AD is an injury risk that might end up hurting me.

Obviously, Schaub would be a nice addition to the trade and is a big point earner when he's on the field. He earned more PPG than AJ did last season in my league. And, the guy who has him also has Eli and McNabb so he might not be too adverse to dealing him.

So, do you guys think this trade would make my team better?